Which of these games is your favorite?

Chaos wrote:

I agree with Ferrety, I haven't really played any of these games except for Spore (which I haven't played that much either.)

Also, aren't we missing Left 4 Dead 2 in this poll?

Is LFD 2 a creating game? No.

IcySquirrel027 wrote:

Chaos wrote:

I agree with Ferrety, I haven't really played any of these games except for Spore (which I haven't played that much either.)

Also, aren't we missing Left 4 Dead 2 in this poll?

Is LFD 2 a creating game? No.

The question says: Which Is Best?

It does NOT say: Which one is the best creating game?

Then the OP should be more specific

Did you even read the OP? It's the title that needs to be more pacific.

IcySquirrel027 wrote:

Did you even read the OP? It's the title that needs to be more pacific.

Lol, i must have missed it Point well taken Squirrel.
Though the title and the poll question were deceptive

Indeed

((Chaos, refrain from using the "A" word in sigs))

Again, GA FTW!!!!!

Ferrety wrote:

I'm not voting on this one, because I've only played Spore. To be honest, if I had a PS3 I'd buy LBP2, just because of the fact that I'd perfer to make a 2D platformer than a 3D thing with flawed controls, slow weapons and glitches. And I have no interest in playing MineCraft.

aw yeah son. the level creation takes a lot of practice though, but you can get some fantastic results

I spent a while playing LBP 2, and I've got a pretty awesome level going so far. I loaded my brain up with a bunch of tutorials, so I decided to make an ice level. I *ahem* "persuaded" my brother to find a roundabout way of getting me the ice background, since I didn't have it before from LBP 1. So I made a super cool entrance that's shaped like a giant mouth and I made a sheet of ice (actually glass) with some jump pads at the beginning to launch the player at the beginning of the level.

So basically, the story of the level will be very simple: you start out talking to a soldier at a little outpost at the beginning of the level. He tells you to go to the main outpost for some reason I haven't yet determined, and he also gives you a creatinator that shoots fire. That will be the weapon used to beat enemies and solve puzzles throughout the level. Once you get to the base, you win. Since it's my first level, I didn't really want it to be too complicated.

One thing I'd like to say in the favor of LBP: The physics are very realistic. Objects actually have different masses depending on what material they are made of, so they react differently when being moved by the player and with each other. Also, one of the things that made me skeptical about getting the first LBP was the lack of realistic NPCs. You had to make NPCs out of objects yourself, and they didn't have AI or anything. But now, in LBP 2, we have a new thing: SACKBOTS. They're like little sack people that you can customize and edit, just like the NPCs in GA.

That's all I have to say for now. If you don't yet own any of the LBP games, I suggest you get one. It's pretty amazing.

I'm starting on one, once I find that moving water material. maybe a steampunk one, where you run around on the inside and outside of a massive airship. (what's your id gelo, I want to add you now?)

I don't have one ATM. I'll get around to it eventually, though.

Dark_Heroics wrote:

(what's your id gelo, I want to add you now?)

I just got a new ID. The same as my Spore and GAC username: Gelatino95

adding powers activate I've got a really short intro movie up now for that adventure btw

I've now had extensive exposure to all three of the games in the poll, so here's a pro/con list I have compiled:
___________________________________________________________________________

Spore GA

PROS:
Best 3D design
Very realistic NPCs
Rewards anyone who plays your adventures
Best medium for making stories

CONS:
Super glitchy
Sub-par graphics
Unrealistic physics
Limited to 8 acts

LittleBigPlanet (2)

PROS:
INCREDIBLE graphics
Best versatility
Realistic NPCs
Unlimited, as long as it fits within complexity limit

CONS:
For the most part, it's 2D
Fixed player with limited customization
Hard to make dialogue
Hard to learn (way too many tutorials)

Minecraft

PROS:
Nearly unlimited building capabilities
Easy to make interiors
Multiplayer
Nearly everything can be customized

CONS:
No story-making capability
Bad graphics
Too many video game elements (HP, enemies, ect.)
Resources must be manually produced
___________________________________________________________________________

NOTE: Many of these are based on opinion, and therefore could be considered either a pro or a con. If you have any questions about what certain things mean, ask.

Gelatino95 wrote:

I've now had extensive exposure to all three of the games in the poll, so here's a pro/con list I have compiled:
___________________________________________________________________________

Spore GA

PROS:
Best 3D design
Very realistic NPCs
Rewards anyone who plays your adventures
Best medium for making stories

CONS:
Super glitchy
Sub-par graphics
Unrealistic physics
Limited to 8 acts

LittleBigPlanet (2)

PROS:
INCREDIBLE graphics
Best versatility
Realistic NPCs
Unlimited, as long as it fits within complexity limit

CONS:
For the most part, it's 2D
Fixed player with limited customization
Hard to make dialogue
Hard to learn (way too many tutorials)

Minecraft

PROS:
Nearly unlimited building capabilities
Easy to make interiors
Multiplayer
Nearly everything can be customized

CONS:
No story-making capability
Bad graphics
Too many video game elements (HP, enemies, ect.)
Resources must be manually produced
___________________________________________________________________________

NOTE: Many of these are based on opinion, and therefore could be considered either a pro or a con. If you have any questions about what certain things mean, ask.

Very good Gelo. Why don't you give each game a rating? 1 - 5 stars maybe?

Also, the reason Minecraft has to many video game elements is because it is to supposed to be a game like Spore or LBP. That's what Creative is for. Survival is well, survival.

Like I said, Gamer, they are based on opinion. I consider the video game elements a negative feature of what would normally be a better creating game, so I made them a con.

Gelatino95 wrote:

Like I said, Gamer, they are based on opinion. I consider the video game elements a negative feature of what would normally be a better creating game, so I made them a con.

Yes, I know. It is ok to state opinion.

I never saw minecraft as a creative game, more as a mess around and do whatever game

Dark_Heroics wrote:

I never saw minecraft as a creative game, more as a mess around and do whatever game

That is because it is. Minecraft is not a creative game.

Minecraft FTW. But iam playing both, both are way to good. And do you know how many Spore players have migrated to mincraft?!?!

But an even better question:

How many play BOTH!

-----

I have no idea, but me is one of them!

Superted64 wrote:

Minecraft FTW. But iam playing both, both are way to good. And do you know how many Spore players have migrated to mincraft?!?!

But an even better question:

How many play BOTH!

-----

I have no idea, but me is one of them!

I used to play both. Now I only play Minecraft.

IcySquirrel027 wrote:

Superted64 wrote:

Minecraft FTW. But iam playing both, both are way to good. And do you know how many Spore players have migrated to mincraft?!?!

But an even better question:

How many play BOTH!

-----

I have no idea, but me is one of them!

I used to play both. Now I only play Minecraft.

awwwwww well, both of them are way too good to ditch! BTW if you happen to play SMP, try the

Wrath Server, iam an admin there. IP: smp.wrtahmc.com

Cya there! Maybe.

Superted64 wrote:

IcySquirrel027 wrote:

Superted64 wrote:

Minecraft FTW. But iam playing both, both are way to good. And do you know how many Spore players have migrated to mincraft?!?!

But an even better question:

How many play BOTH!

-----

I have no idea, but me is one of them!

I used to play both. Now I only play Minecraft.

awwwwww well, both of them are way too good to ditch! BTW if you happen to play SMP, try the

Wrath Server, iam an admin there. IP: smp.wrtahmc.com

Cya there! Maybe.

I do indeed play SMP. I love "hardcore survival PvP". There is a server I found that fits the perfectly. Check out page 7 of Minecraft Discussion for IP.

Any LBP 2 fans should check this out:

SO MUCH WIN GELO. Clive's the best isn't he? all depressed and communist... or was he a capitalist? or an anarchist?

Am I the only one who likes lbp?

Gelatino95 wrote:

Any LBP 2 fans should check this out:

Clive Handforth, perhaps?
(or marvin the robot.)